The Fate Trap: Why Believing in Destiny Diminishes Your Power

The Fate Trap: Why Believing in Destiny Diminishes Your Power
Photo by petr sidorov / Unsplash
"It was meant to be."
"Everything happens for a reason."
"What's meant for you will find you."

These phrases roll off our tongues to offer comfort in difficult times and explanation for life's mysteries. But they come with a hidden cost: they quietly undermine our capacity to shape our own lives.

The Seductive Appeal of Fate

Belief in fate offers psychological comfort and relieves us of responsibility. When we face setbacks or disappointments, the idea that these events serve some greater purpose can help us cope with pain and uncertainty. It's easier to accept a job rejection or a failed relationship when we frame it as part of a predetermined plan rather than random misfortune or the consequence of our own choices. If our lives are already mapped out by cosmic forces, we can't be blamed for failures or fully credited for successes.

The Hidden Cost

But this comfort creates a passive approach to life. Why put in extra effort at work if promotions are destined? Why actively work on relationships if the "right person" will simply appear? When we believe our paths are already written, we reduce our engagement with creating our lives.

This becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. When we believe we have little control over outcomes, we invest less energy in pursuing goals, make fewer attempts, and give up more quickly. The result is often exactly what we expected: a life that feels predetermined because we've limited our own agency.

The Neuroscience of Choice

Modern research reveals that when we believe we have agency, our brains actively engage in predictive processing, generating creative solutions and motivating action. When we believe our futures are predetermined, this crucial cognitive machinery becomes less active. People who believe in their ability to influence outcomes are more likely to persist through challenges, seek out opportunities, and recover from setbacks. They see more possibilities because their brains are primed to look for them. Conversely, those who believe in fate often develop what psychologists call "learned helplessness," a state where they stop trying even when action could make a difference.

Reclaiming Your Authorship

This doesn't mean we control everything. Genetics, economics, natural disasters, and countless other factors influence our lives in ways we can't direct. But between total control and no control lies a vast middle ground where our choices genuinely matter.

Consider your career: while you can't control the entire job market or guarantee that any particular opportunity will work out, you can influence your prospects through skill development, networking, and performance improvement. The person who believes their path is fated might send out a few resumes and wait for destiny to deliver the perfect job. The person who believes in their agency will continuously develop skills, build relationships, seek feedback, and create opportunities.

A More Empowering Perspective

Instead of fate, embrace what philosophers call "compatibilism"—the view that free will and determinism can coexist. We can acknowledge the constraints that shape our lives, while recognizing our capacity to make meaningful choices within those parameters.

Your life isn't a predetermined script waiting to be performed. It's a creative work in progress, with you as both author and protagonist. The next chapter isn't written yet, and that's not a source of anxiety: it's the foundation of all possibility.

Read more